Five agricultural groups have filed a court brief asking the U.S. Court of International Trade to overturn tariffs imposed on phosphate fertilizers from Morocco, arguing the tariffs have given Mosaic Co. “near-monopoly” status when it comes to phosphate fertilizer.
The commodity groups are joining an appeal against a decision by the International Trade Commission (ITC) last March to impose 19% tariffs on phosphate fertilizers from Morocco. The ruling imposed tariffs for five years.
The ITC imposed the tariffs on Moroccan phosphate products after a petition filed by Mosaic Co. led to the tariff recommendation from the U.S. Department of Commerce. The ITC imposed the tariffs along with tariffs on Russian phosphate fertilizer. The ITC ruled that the U.S. fertilizer industry was harmed by subsidies that Morocco and Russia provided their industries.
In their brief, the farm groups state the ITC incorrectly blamed a supply imbalance in 2019 on imports. The commission didn’t take into account U.S. fertilizer producers idling plants while increasing exports. The commodity groups pointed to Mosaic and Nutrien announcing separately they would idle and close plants, taking roughly 2.1 million short tons of North American production offline.
A series of wet weather events in 2018 and 2019 reduced planted acres as well, further changing demand.
“Domestic (fertilizer) producers were well aware of these market dynamics and aware that their decision to reduce domestic production dictated an increase in import supply,” the commodity groups stated in their brief.
The commodity groups also stated the ITC was wrong to rule that imports were unnecessary to meet farmer needs in 2019.
The commodity groups noted, “As a result, critical sources of imported supply have been shut out of the U.S. market, and the costs of fertilizers have increased for farmers.”
DAP is now averaging $810 a ton, as DTN’s fertilizer column highlighted last week. DAP topped $800 a ton for the first time since December 2008 and 82% higher than a year ago. MAP is averaging $863 a ton, up 81% from a year ago. (See here)
The commodity groups added that Mosaic’s control of the phosphate market has grown from 74% to more than 80%, “gaining a near-monopoly over the phosphate fertilizer supply in the U.S.” The letter notes Mosaic’s stock price has quadrupled since March 2020.
AgFax Weed Solutions
“I struggle as a farmer when they tell me that one company has 73%-74% of the market share and we’re going to put tariffs in place that will let them get to 80%-plus, and that’s exactly what’s happened here,” said Chris Edgington, an Iowa farmer and president of the National Corn Growers Association, in an interview with DTN. Edgington added, “It’s hard to imagine that we gave that much leverage to one company.”
The commodity groups were granted the ability to file an amicus brief in the appeal filed by Morocco’s major fertilizer company, OCP, as well as fertilizer importers and suppliers including Koch Fertilizer. But Mosaic and J.R Simplot Co. have objected to the commodity groups’ weighing in with a brief.
The court now has two weeks to decide whether to accept the brief and be allowed for use materially as the U.S. Court of International Trade rules on the appeal against the tariffs. Even if the commodity groups are successful in keeping their brief before the court, the court likely would not issue a decision until mid-2022.
“From a producer standpoint, you’re now talking about 2023’s crop,” Edgington said. He added, “That means we’re going to be under this tariff situation for next year regardless. And even if we get a favorable ruling, the retailers are going to have this inventory of high-priced product.”
Mosaic will release its third-quarter earnings after the stock market close on Monday.
Mosaic has been reporting that its sales volume of phosphates is down from a year ago, but its revenues on phosphate sales are up. In May, Mosaic reported 553,000 metric tons of phosphate sold, down 55,000 tons, compared to May 2020, but revenue was up $113 million to $327 million.
In August, Mosaic announced it had sold 666,000 metric tons of phosphate, down 77,000 tons from a year earlier. Revenues in August, though, were up $204 million compared to 2020, reaching $465 million in phosphate sales.
The commodity groups note that one of the arguments in the brief focuses on a decision by Mosaic in 2017 to idle two facilities, which caused a shortage of fertilizers for U.S. farmers during the 2018 planting season. That led farmers and their suppliers to buy more phosphate fertilizer from other countries.
The move by the commodities groups to challenge the ruling on phosphate fertilizers also comes as the Department of Commerce is reviewing a petition by CF Industries to place antidumping and countervailing duties against ammonium nitrate fertilizers from Russia and the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago. The industry is waiting now on the Commerce Department’s preliminary conclusions in its investigation.
The commodity groups filing the brief included NCGA, along with the Agricultural Retailers Association, American Soybean Association, the National Cotton Council and the National Sorghum Producers.
Chris Clayton can be reached at Chris.Clayton@dtn.com
Follow him on Twitter @ChrisClaytonDTN