Pennsylvania Corn: Managing Belowground Insect Pests

    Seedcorn maggot in hollowed out corn seed. Photo: Purdue University

    Belowground insect pests can be challenging to control. In common field crops of Pennsylvania, they can occur in soybeans, small grains, or hay, but tend not to be too problematic in these crops. By contrast, belowground pests can be challenging in corn production (grain or silage), particularly when it is grown in the same fields year after year.

    Other than continuous corn production, underground pests tend to be sporadic in corn fields that have been rotated annually—some fields have the same pest year after year and others do not have any issues. Many of these pests cause similar symptoms including missing, wilted, or stunted seedlings.

    The best way to determine if soil-dwelling pests are causing problems in your fields is to scout for them by digging up damaged seedlings or poorly established sections of rows to inspect roots and look for damage.

    Generally, the longer the crop rotation, the fewer belowground insect problems. Longer rotations host a larger variety of plant species through time and few insect pests can feed on all the crop species in a rotation so pest populations do not build when their development is disrupted.

    By contrast, planting the same species year after year gives pests easy access to a predictable food source and their populations will build with time. Should you have problems with belowground insect pests, most species can be controlled with soil- or seed-applied insecticides.

    Bt traits in corn hybrids are only useful belowground for rootworms, but keep in mind that control tactics are only useful when pest populations are present. Moreover, in wet years, insecticides, particularly the neonicotinoids, can be less effective because they are water soluble and can be diluted out of the root zone, decreasing efficacy.

    Always identify your pest species first and use appropriate controls. Below are summaries of the most common belowground insect pests in Pennsylvania corn fields.

    Seedcorn maggot

    Figure 1. Adult Delia fly (top left) Image Credit: Image Number: 5312054, Pest and Diseases Image Library, Bugwood.org. Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 License; Larvae feeding damage to corn seeds (top right and bottom) Image Credit: Image Number: 5434908 and 5434908, Mariusz Sobieski, Bugwood.org. Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommerical 3.0 License

    Seedcorn maggot is primarily a pest in tilled corn fields. In rare cases, it can attack soybeans, but again typically in tilled fields. Seedcorn maggot can complete 3-5 generations per growing season (Figures 1 and 2) but of course the generations that align with crop establishment are most problematic.

    AgFax Weed Solutions


    Adult flies lay eggs in fields, and maggots burrow into the seed, destroying the seed germ, but they can also attack underground stems. Seedcorn maggots prefer decaying organic matter, so there is a higher risk after tilling manure or cover crops into the soil.

    No rescue treatments are available for seedcorn maggot; however, in tilled fields, the risk of seedcorn maggot can be reduced by planting at least two weeks after tillage to allow organic matter to break down. Alternatively, farmers can decrease their risk from seedcorn maggot by planting shallowly in warm soil, which allows seeds to germinate quickly.

    Another option is to plant during the fly-free period. This requires calculating the growing degree days, with a base of 39°F, to determine when the maggots will be present and potentially cause feeding damage (Figure 3). Seedcorn maggot is easily controlled with seed or soil-applied insecticides at planting.

    Figure 2. Seedcorn maggot life cycle, including number of growing degree days (GDD, base 39F) that are needed to complete each stage. Credit: Nick Sloff, Penn State University.

    Delia Growth Stage Cumulative Growing Degree Days (GDD) Activity
    Peak adult emergence of first generation 360 Egg laying
    Larvae emerge from eggs 414
    Three larval instars 414- 781 Feeding damage
    Pupation 781 – 1051 “Fly-free” period. No feeding.
    Adults emerge and reproduce 1116 Egg laying occurs
    Larvae of second generation emerge from eggs 1170
    Three larval instars 1170 – 1537 Feeding damage
    Pupation 1170 – 1807 “Fly-free” period. No feeding.
    Adults emerge & reproduce 1872 Egg laying
    Larvae of third generation emerge from eggs 1926
    Three larval instars 1926- 2293 Feeding damage
    Pupation 2293 – 2563 (or next season) “Fly-free” period. No feeding.

    Figure 3. Cumulative growing degree days for seedcorn maggot to reach “fly-free” periods.

    Wireworms

    Figure 4. Wire worms are the larvae of click beetles. Image Credit: (left) Anna Busch, Penn State Extension; (right) Image Number UGA1435036 Clemson University – USDA Cooperative Extension Slide Series, Bugwood.org, Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommerical 3.0 License.

    Wireworms are larvae of click beetles (Figure 4). Females lay eggs in grassy areas or cultivated fields, making corn at a higher risk when it follows hay, pasture, or alfalfa. The larvae take 2-3 years to develop and have overlapping generations.

    Due to their long development time, wireworm issues can persist for multiple years, but most fields in Pennsylvania are never colonized by significant populations of wireworms. Wireworm larvae feed on below ground plant tissue, boring into stems and roots.

    Spring tillage can help decrease wireworm damage and they are easily controlled with seed or soil-applied insecticides at planting.

    White grubs

    White grubs represent multiple species of scarab beetle larvae. This includes Japanese beetles, European chaffers, and June beetles (Figure 5). Not all white grubs are pests. Some species are manure feeders.

    Unless they are in the root zone, they are unlikely to be pests. Larger species are more concerning due to the amount of feeding damage they can cause. The different species can be identified based on patterns of hairs on the tip of their abdomens, and this information can be easily found through various online resources.

    Figure 5. White grubs represent multiple species that vary in size (Left to right, Japanese beetle, European chaffer, June beetles). Image Credit: Image Number: UGA1192024, David Cappaert, Bugwood.org, licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 License.

    White grubs feed on roots and are more likely to damage corn that follows alfalfa, hay, or pasture. Symptoms include missing, wilted, or stunted seedlings. Most fields never see infestations, but some fields are regularly infested. White grubs can be controlled with seed- or soil-applied insecticides at planting.

    Slugs

    Figure 6. Gray garden slug (left) and typical slug feeding damage to corn seedlings (right). Image Credit (left) Nick Sloff, Penn State University; (right) John Tooker, Penn State University.

    Slugs are most abundant in long-term no-till fields, and eat virtually all crops (Figure 6). They inflict most damage to seeds and seedlings during cool, wet conditions when crop growth is slowed. Open furrows facilitate their feeding on seeds and germinating seeds, so ensuring furrow closure can help reduce damage.

    Slugs are molluscs, not insects, so most insecticides are ineffective for controlling slug populations. For severe slug infestations, granular baits are available, but their efficacy can be reduced by rain. Predators like ground beetles and wolf spiders are the best option for control, but they must be kept in mind when farming.

    Using cover crops to attract these beneficials and limiting insecticide use by using Integrated Pest Management can build their populations. Insecticide-treated seeds and broadcast applications of broad-spectrum insecticides both negatively influence invertebrate predator populations and their effects are about equal.

    Western corn rootworm

    Figure 7. Adult corn rootworm (left) and larvae (right). Image Credit (left) Anthony Zukoff, Kansas State University; (right) Pat Porter, Texas A&M University.

    Western corn rootworm is the most problematic pest of corn in the United States and costs growers about a billion dollars annually in damage and pest control expenses (Figure 7). In Pennsylvania, they are only problematic in continuous corn fields, and are not problematic if farmers rotate their corn with soybeans, alfalfa, sorghum among other crops.

    Western corn rootworms overwinter as eggs. The larvae begin feeding on corn roots in late May and are present through early August. Severe larval feeding can greatly reduce root volume, leaving plants vulnerable to lodging when conditions become wet or windy.

    Brand name Bt protein Field-evolved resistance in
    U.S. rootworm populations?
    YieldGardRW Cry3Bbl Yes
    Herculex RW Cry34/35Abl Yes
    Agrisure RW mCry3A Yes
    Agrisure Duracade eCry3.lAB No**

    Table 1. Bt toxins targeting rootworms **not being deployed alone

    Rootworms are tough to control, and populations in the U.S. have evolved resistance against all the management options that have been developed (e.g., soil insecticides, crop rotation, single-toxin Bt corn varieties, and two-toxin Bt corn varieties (Table 1), though not every rootworm population is resistant to all the control tactics.

    In Pennsylvania, we have fewer problems with resistance than growers in the heart of the Cornbelt, but we can still have issues. In Pennsylvania, for example, some fields that have been in corn continuously for just three years have developed populations of rootworm beetles that are effectively resistant to corn hybrids expressing single toxins of Bt.

    As a result, we recommend rotating continuous corn fields to nonhost plants (e.g., soybeans, alfalfa, or sorghum; longer rotations are better), and farmers should strive to avoid growing corn in any one field more than two years in a row.

    If growers need to grow corn continuously, the best management practice is to use Bt hybrids that have at least two toxins for controlling rootworms.

    Alternatively, growers can consider using untraited corn with a soil insecticide at planting—this option is better than putting insecticides over the top of Bt seed targeting rootworms because the cost of untraited seed can be significantly lower than Bt seed.




    The Latest


    Send press releases to Ernst@Agfax.com.

    View All Events


    Send press releases to Ernst@Agfax.com.

    View All Events