Thursday, June 19, 2014
benfranklin_100

Crop Insurance Overlap with PLC

AgFax.Com - Your Online Ag News Source


Overview

This article addresses the potential for overlap that can exist between crop insurance and the Price Loss Coverage (PLC) program option in the 2014 farm bill.  To provide perspective, the historical overlap that existed between target prices and crop insurance prices from 1974 through 2006 is examined.  The article ends with summary observations including implications for policy and the upcoming farm program decision by farmers.




Policy Background

Target prices began with the 1973 farm bill.  They have existed ever since except for the 1996-2001 crop years when the 1996 farm bill replaced target price payments with direct payments.  PLC is the latest version of target price programs.  It refers to target prices as reference prices.  All target price programs have made payments when the market price is below the target price, although different farm bills have used different measures of market price.

Price Decline Overlap

PLC and crop insurance can make payments for the same price decline if

(1)     price declines between the insurance pre-plant and harvest price discovery periods, and

(2)     the price decline continues throughout the ensuing crop marketing year resulting in a crop year average price that is less than the PLC reference price.

Analysis

The potential for this overlap is examined using target prices for the 1974-1995 and 2002-0606 crop years for the economically and politically important crops of corn, rice, sorghum, soybeans, upland cotton, and wheat.  This period was selected in part because market prices exhibited no sustained upward or downward trend.  Trends affect the probability of payment by target price programs.

The target prices are from Agricultural Statistics, an annual U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) publication.  Crop year average prices are from the USDA, National Agricultural Statistics Service (NASS) Quick Stats database.  Consistent with PLC, per unit deficiency payment is calculated as the Target Price minus the U.S. crop year average price.

Insurance prices for 2000 and forward are from the Risk Management Agency (RMA) website.  For earlier years, a data set created by Art Barnaby of Kansas State University is used.  RMA did not compute harvest insurance prices prior to the introduction of revenue insurance, which began with Crop Revenue Coverage (CRC) in 1996.  However, Art estimated harvest prices for prior years using RMA methods.  Note that crop insurance was not offered for rice until the 1987 crop year and the insurance price used for wheat is the price based on the Chicago futures market.

Findings

The insurance price declined between the pre-plant and harvest price discovery periods in about 50% of all years as well as during only those years in which a deficiency payment occurred (Figure 1).  Such a finding was expected because insurance prices for the examined crops are based on futures prices.  It is widely-accepted that futures prices are unbiased price estimates and that new bullish and bearish price information is generated randomly.  Hence price increases and decreases about 50% of the time.

figur1.jpg

Click Image to Enlarge

During the years a deficiency payment was made and insurance price declined, average per unit deficiency payment expressed as a percent of the pre-plant insurance price exceeded average decline in insurance price for all crops (Figure 2).  The smallest difference is for corn:  a -15% decline in insurance price vs. a per unit deficiency payment that averaged 18% of the insurance pre-plant price.

The largest difference is for rice: a -18% decline in insurance price vs. a deficiency payment that averaged 59% of the insurance pre-plant price.  It should be noted that the average decline in insurance price is similar among crops, ranging from -13% for wheat to -18% for rice.  Again, this finding was expected for reasons discussed in the previous paragraph.

figur2.jpg

Click Image to Enlarge

Summary Observations

  • An overlap can exist between target price deficiency payments and declines in crop insurance price between the pre-plant and harvest price discovery periods.
  • The exact degree of overlap expected between PLC and crop insurance is difficult to calculate because PLC pays on 85 percent of FSA farms’ base acres while insurance pays on 100% of acres planted on the insured unit.  Nevertheless, this overlap has the potential to be large as illustrated by the historical experiences during the 1974-1995 and 2002-2006 crop years.
  • A policy issue is whether the deficiency payments that coincide with the insurance deductible is an overlap.  Farmers will not likely view this part of PLC payments as an overlap.  However, the social contract which underpins public subsidies for farm insurance is that a partnership exists between society and farmers in managing farm production and revenue risk.  The farmer’s share of this partnership involves the insurance deductible and payment of a premium.  PLC payments alter the deductible component of the social contract.
  • Given that crop revenue insurance is a key, if not the key, component of the crop safety net, an obvious policy question is whether the overlap between PLC reference prices and crop revenue insurance prices should be considered when designing the crop safety net?  More specifically, should the overlap be eliminated by integrating the prices of the two programs?
  • A related, interesting historical policy question is whether the elimination of target prices between 1996 and 2001 by the 1996 farm bill allowed revenue insurance products to gain traction, thereby altering the future path of farm policy debates?
  • Farmers should consider the insurance – PLC overlap when making their farm program choice.  Overlapping payments would provide additional government assistance if prices decline and stay below the PLC reference prices.  Electing PLC also creates the potential for substituting PLC for crop revenue insurance in terms of providing assistance against price declines.  This substitution allows farmers to replace revenue insurance with cheaper yield insurance.
  • Because the new insurance Supplemental Coverage Option is only available if PLC is elected, insurance companies and agents have an economic self-interest in promoting PLC as the farm program choice.  However, the potential to replace higher premium revenue insurance with lower premium yield insurance when deficiency payments are expected blunts this economic self-interest.  It will be interesting to see how these competing impacts play out.

Carl Zulauf

farmdocDaily


Tags: , , , , , ,


Leave a Reply

Name and Email Address are required fields. Your email will not be published or shared with third parties.

Sunbelt Ag News

    DTN Cotton Open: Trades Slightly Lower within Tight Span8-27

    DTN Livestock Open: Hog Paper to Recover Further8-27

    DTN Grain Open: Soybeans Start Out Higher8-27

    Keith Good: Net Farm Income Forecast at $113.2B, Down 13.8% from 20138-27

    Cotton in Southwest – Early Yield Reports Good; Oklahoma Needs Rain – AgFax8-26

    Grain TV: Sept.-Nov. Soy Spread Unwinds8-26

    Weather, Insects, Equipment Insurance, Health Issues – What Else? – DTN8-26

    DTN Livestock Close: Oversold Lean Hog Futures Move Sharply Higher8-26

    DTN Fertilizer Trends: Prices Unlikely to See Significant Declines8-26

    Doane Cotton Close: Dec. Tops 40-Day Average8-26

    Will High Yields Rescue 2014 Crop Returns? Not for Many.8-26

    AFB Grain-Soybean Close: Big Drop in Soy, Corn Down, Wheat Mostly Higher8-26

    AFB Cotton Close: Dec. Continues to Work Higher8-26

    AFB Rice Close: Trades Lower withing Yesterday’s Range8-26

    Your Farm Business and the Affordable Care Act8-26

    DTN Cotton Close: Highest Finish in a Month8-26

    AgFax Grain Review: Midwest Storage Concerns; Cereal Rye Makes Good Cover Crop8-26

    DTN Grain Close: Steady To Lower; September Beans Plummet8-26

    USDA: Weekly National Peanut Prices8-26

    DTN Livestock Midday: Hog Futures Lead Complex Higher8-26

    DTN Grain Midday: Soybeans Leading Trade Lower8-26

    Pork: U.S. Exports to Japan Increase but Competition is Growing — DTN8-26

    Arkansas: UA Cotton Field Day Slated Sept. 9 at Manila8-26

    Missouri: Fisher Delta Center Field Day Set Sept. 2 in Portageville8-26

    Doane Cotton Close: Finishes Down Very Slightly8-25

    Corn Rootworm Researchers Handcuffed by Time — DTN8-25

    Good on Grain: Looking for a Corn Consumption Response8-25

    DTN Fertilizer Outlook: Domestic Ammonia Prices Increase8-25

    Environmental Health: Farm-Based Nitrogen Emissions Unavoidable, Can Be Minimized8-25

    Brazil Soybeans: Prices Slide as Acreage Rises — DTN8-25

    Flint on Crops: Stress Avoidance Critical for Crops — and People8-25

    Shurley on Cotton: Prices Show Faint Signs of Life8-25

    Cleveland on Cotton: Heavy Hat Sitting on 67-68 Cent Mark8-22

    Rice Crop: Harvest Progresses in Texas, Louisiana; Arkansas Farmers Unpaid8-22

    Rice Market: Futures Push to New High Before Hit with Selling Pressure8-22

    Peanuts – Drought, Dry-Weather Pests Persist in Lower Southeast – AgFax8-22

    Southern Soybeans – Midsouth Harvest Widens – AgFax8-22

    Rice Harvest Starts In Arkansas, Barely – AgFax8-22

    Cotton In Midsouth – Bollworms Build – AgFax8-22

    Mississippi Hunting: Plant Proper Fields for Upcoming Dove Season8-22

    Taxes: Donating Crops Can Mean Substantial Tax Savings8-22

    Georgia Peanut Commission Promotes Consumption Through Sporting Events8-22

    USDA: Peanut Price Highlights8-22

    Georgia: Pecan Growers Association Field Day, Tifton, Sept. 48-22

    Mississippi Soybeans: Growers Anticipate Record Yield8-22

    Farming on the Mother Road: Change is Operative Word in New Mexico – DTN8-22

    Mississippi: Cool-Season Food Plots Benefit Wildlife, Diversity8-22

    Beef Checkoff Effort Stalls – DTN8-21

    Farming on the Mother Road: Amarillo, Heart of Cattle Feed Country – DTN8-21

    Biofuels: Nebraska Switchgrass Cultivar Provides Promise – DTN8-21

    Louisiana: Rice Disease Field Tour, Crowley, Aug. 268-21

    Chumrau on Wheat: Large World Supply Is Certain, Quality Is the Question8-21

    U.S. Grain Transportation: STB Takes Steps to Resolve Rail Backlog8-21

    U.S. Drought Outlook: Improvement Across Southwest, California Still Dry8-21

    U.S. Energy: Midland Crude Prices Falling Below Cushing Prices8-21

    Gasoline Prices: Decrease by 3 Cents8-21

    Propane Stocks: Up 2.5M Barrels8-21

    Diesel Prices: Average Drops 1 Cent8-21

    Sunbelt Ag Events

    Rice News

     

    About Us

    AgFax.Com covers agricultural trends and production topics, with an emphasis on news about cotton, rice, peanuts, corn, soybeans, wheat and tree crops, including almonds, pecans, walnuts and pistachios.

      

    This site also serves as the on-line presence of electronic crop and pest reports published by AgFax Media LLC (formerly Looking South Communications).

        

    Click here to subscribe to our free reports.

      

    We provide early warnings and confirmations about pests, diseases and other factors that influence yield. Our goal is to quickly provide farmers and crop advisors with information needed to make better and more profitable decisions.

         

    Our free weekly crop and pest advisories include:

    • AgFax Midsouth Cotton, covering cotton production and news in Alabama, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Tennessee and Missouri.

    • AgFax Southeast Cotton, covering cotton production and news in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina and Virginia.

    • AgFax Southwest Cotton (new for 2013!), covering cotton production and news in Texas, Oklahoma, Kansas and New Mexico.

    • AgFax West (formerly MiteFax: SJV Cotton), covering California cotton, alfalfa, tomatoes and other non-permanent crops in California's Central Valley.

    • AgFax Rice covering rice production and news in Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri and Texas.

    • AgFax Peanuts, covering peanut production in Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, Texas and Virginia.

    • AgFax Southern Grain: covering soybeans, corn, milo and small grains in Southern states.

    • AgFax Almonds, covering almonds, pistachios, walnuts and other tree crops in California's Central Valley.

    • AgCom 101, providing guidance to ag professionals involved in social media.

    Our newsletters are sponsored by the following companies: FMC Corporation Chemtura Dow AgroSciences.

          

    Mission statement:

    Make it as easy as possible for our community of readers to find and/or receive needed information.

              

    Contact Information:

    AgFax Media. LLC

    142 Westlake Drive Brandon, MS 39047

    601-992-9488 Office 601-992-3503 Fax

    Owen Taylor Debra L. Ferguson Laurie Courtney

          

    Circulation Questions?

    Contact Laurie Courtney