Agfax Buzz:
    April 21, 2012

    Mississippi: Glyphosate Resistant Weeds Are Bad, But Soil Loss Worse

    AgFax.Com - Your Online Ag News Source

    By Ernie Flint, Area Agronomist, Mississippi State University Extension Service

    Herbicide resistance in some of our most competitive weeds has proven to be one of the greatest challenges to agriculture. Every year we learn of new weed species. We have come to believe that certain products are necessary for growing crops, at least on the large scale we have come to accept as the norm. However, we are being forced to modify the crop production systems that have evolved over the past two decades or more.

    The “keystone” of this dilemma is that more and more weeds are becoming resistant to the herbicide glyphosate. When we began hearing stories about glyphosate resistant horseweed, most people chose to ignore it since this was not a weed we normally considered as competitive in our crops. A trip across Missouri about 7 years ago convinced me that our perception of this weed was incorrect, and now we have it in abundance in most of our crop production areas.

    Since that time, other weeds have entered the ranks of glyphosate resistance, with some having resistance to multiple classes of herbicides. I will leave the technical aspects of this subject to the weed scientists, but I do see the issue from the farmers’ viewpoint. The reality of herbicide resistance has in their view become an extremely difficult problem that threatens profitability, farm sustainability, and ultimately the ability to continue farming.

    Herbicide resistance in weeds like horseweed, pigweed(s), Johnsongrass, ryegrass, and others is threatening to change our production systems in very dramatic ways. Some growers have returned to conventional tillage after years of reduced tillage and no-tillage farming. Herbicides that have not been used on a large scale in decades, such as trifluralin, are being returned to service as a way of preventing the emergence of these “monster” weeds.




    A “background” issue in this discussion is that of compromised soil conservation practices. The great achievements we have seen in the reduction of soil and nutrient loss are being challenged by the perceived necessity for a return to tillage as means of dealing with weed resistance. This issue is in fact as big a “deal” as the more apparent problem of weed resistance since it impacts long term sustainability. Simply said, “if we lose our soil, we’re finished anyway.”

    A current discussion among some of the producers I work with is how to deal with resistant Italian ryegrass on sloping fields that are very susceptible to soil erosion. The need to avoid tillage on these fields is very evident, but planting through ryegrass is not a viable option. One suggestion has been to apply strong pre-emergence herbicides in the fall as a means of keeping fields “clean” through the winter months. While this may be preferable to tillage, this method will lead to increased soil loss. We need to find an alternative that will solve this question.

    One method may be to plant a cover crop such as wheat, then apply broad spectrum herbicides commonly used in that crop. There are a choice of materials, which would need to be evaluated for effectiveness and tolerance of summer crops planted after the wheat stand is destroyed. This system would likely have multiple benefits of the desired suppression of weeds, soil stabilization, conservation of nutrients, and increased soil organic matter.  In some years, the grower might also choose to harvest the wheat for grain if prices supported that decision.

    Others may find holes in this idea large enough to drive a bus through, however we have to begin work toward not only growing crops profitably but also protecting the land for the future. This method, or some other idea, may already be in use somewhere, if so, I hope to talk with those who have made it work. Either way, we have to try other methods before we return to the destructive farming methods of the past.

    Thanks for your time.


    Tags: , , , ,

    Leave a Reply

    Name and Email Address are required fields. Your email will not be published or shared with third parties.

    Agfax Cotton News

    Keith Good: Fight Against PED Virus Accelerates as Pork Prices Climb10-2

    DTN Cotton Close: Settles to Marginal Losses10-1

    Florida: Nematodes Create Problems in Multiple Crops10-1

    DTN Fertilizer Trends: State Averages for Anhydrous Vary Widely10-1

    DTN Cotton Open: Edges Higher within Tight Ranges10-1

    Keith Good: U.S., Brazil Reportedly Agree to Settle Cotton Dispute10-1

    Farm Bill Decision Deadlines and the Farm Bill Toolbox9-30

    Doane Cotton Close: Analyst Predicts 40 Cent Futures9-30

    AFB Cotton Close: Futures in the Red9-30

    DTN Cotton Close: Slips to New Lows9-30

    AgFax Cotton Review: Global Supply Hurts Prices; Cotton Transition Assistance Program Deadline Looms9-30

    Texas Crop Weather: Hay Supplies Range from Surplus to Practically Non-Existent9-30

    DTN Cotton Open: Trades on Slight Loss Near Low9-30

    Keith Good: ‘Misinformation’ Muddles Clean Water Act, EPA Chief Says9-30

    California: Rice Harvest Progress as Rains Move Through Northern Areas – USDA9-29

    AFB Cotton Close: Inside Day Finishes Lower9-29

    South Carolina: Rains Halt Peanut Harvest, Field Work – USDA9-29

    Alabama: Harvest Advances as Dry Weather Persists – USDA9-29

    Mississippi: Dry Weather Prevails, Good for Field Work — USDA9-29

    Arkansas: Corn, Rice Harvest Start to Wind Down – USDA9-29

    Georgia: Weather Causes Issues in Some Areas — USDA9-29

    Texas: Harvest, Wheat Planting Continue Among Widespread Rains – USDA9-29

    Oklahoma: Limited Moisture for Winter Wheat Seedlings – USDA9-29

    Arizona: Cotton Harvest Begins, Crop Condition Good — USDA9-29

    Doane Cotton Close: Harvest Progress Still Sluggish9-29

    North Carolina: Rains Delay Harvest, Corn Harvest 71% Complete – USDA9-29

    Kansas: Rains Slow Harvest, Wheat Planting – USDA9-29

    DTN Cotton Close: Finishes Inside Day Slightly Lower9-29

    Virginia: Rains Slow Corn Harvest – USDA9-29

    Tennessee: Good Harvest Progress, Pastures Need Rain – USDA9-29

    Soybean Harvest Rises by 7 Points, Corn 5 — DTN9-29

    Missouri: Corn, Rice Harvest Make Good Progress, Soybean Harvest Begins – USDA9-29

    DTN Cotton Open: Trades Near Unchanged in December9-29

    Tennessee Cotton: Forecast Looks Favorable for Defoliation9-29

    Flint on Crops: What is a Good Variety Worth?9-29

    Keith Good: Plunging Corn, Soybean Prices May Strain Farm Budgets9-29

    Rose on Cotton: Bearish News – We got plenty.9-26

    Cleveland on Cotton: Chinese Moves Send Market into Free Fall9-26

    Doane Cotton Close: May Dip Under 60 Before Reaching Harvest Lows9-26

    AFB Cotton Close: Recovers from Huge Sell Off9-26